UK court upholds Lithuanian extradition request

By Alice Dixon • November 16, 2026
UK court upholds Lithuanian extradition request - lithuanian extradition
The Ombudsman found that prisoners were not, in reality, guaranteed a safe environment.

A UK High Court ruling has upheld the extradition of a Lithuanian national convicted of raping a minor, despite concerns about the country’s prison system. The court found that new evidence about Lithuania’s informal prisoner hierarchy, where those at the bottom are known as “untouchables”, does not overcome the assumption that the country will safeguard inmates from violence under the European Convention on Human Rights.

Assessing prisoner treatment and legal standards

In the case of Gricius v Siauliai Regional Court, Lithuania [2026] EWHC 2925 (Admin), the applicant, a long-term UK resident, had been convicted in Lithuania in 2021 and was ordered to be extradited by District Judge Jackson in March 2025. The appeal centred on the hierarchy inherited from the Soviet era, under which prisoners at the bottom, known as “untouchables”, are particularly vulnerable to exploitation and violence.

Eardley J refused permission for the appeal following a rolled-up hearing, citing the established approach that the presumption of compliance with human rights obligations yields only to clear, cogent, and compelling evidence. This approach has been consistently applied in post-conviction Lithuanian cases, including Urbonas and Barkauskas v Lithuania [2024] EWHC 2815 (Admin).

The applicant argued that recent European Court of Human Rights rulings, which found breaches of Article 3 against low-caste prisoners, necessitate a more thorough analysis for those likely to become “untouchables”. However, Eardley J disagreed, stating that these cases applied the existing approach in Muršić v Croatia to individual prisoners and did not establish a new test. The 2024 report of the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture showed that prisoners could be assigned untouchable status for many reasons, so that risk had already been considered.

Read Also: Cyprus Extradites Russian National to Face Charges

The applicant relied on various reports, including Lithuania’s 2024 national plan, a 2025 report by the Seimas Ombudsman, and two reports by Karolis Liutkevičius, a former human rights adviser to the Lithuanian Prison Service. Mr Liutkevičius described the national plan as a hasty and unfunded “afterthought”, questioned several infrastructure projects, and reported continuing staff shortages and limited efforts to dismantle the caste system.

The Ombudsman found that prisoners were not, in reality, guaranteed a safe environment. Nevertheless, Eardley J found that the presumption of compliance might only be overcome if the authorities’ commitments were found to be insincere. The judge acknowledged “not negligible” steps taken by Lithuania, including efforts to investigate inter-prisoner violence, establish a second unit for high-risk prisoners, and implement violence prevention measures.

Extradition considerations and procedural issues

The court examined additional material, accepting that the presumption of compliance could be lost if the authorities were unwilling or unable to make progress. Although a further report from the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture might impact the decision, the existing evidence was deemed insufficient to overturn it.

The National Crime Agency’s delay in certifying the arrest warrant, which took over three years, was noted, and Eardley J accepted that the district judge may have erred in not considering this factor in the balance, as per Pabian v Poland [2024] EWHC 2431 (Admin). However, the judge ruled that this omission would not have changed the outcome, given the applicant’s awareness of his conviction for a serious offence and his lack of dependent children or caring responsibilities.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *